Article

How to choose an AI SEO agency in Nigeria: 10 questions to ask first

Want more buyers and sales from AI search, without doing the work? Let the IYDigitals team handle it. Talk to an expert now →

How to choose an AI SEO agency in Nigeria: 10 questions to ask first
Quick answerChoose an AI SEO agency in Nigeria by asking what will change for your business in 90 days, seeing results you can verify yourself, agreeing which buyer questions and prompts will be tracked, confirming how enquiries (not just rankings) are measured, getting a clear monthly scope, knowing who does the work, checking for competitor conflicts, asking how links are built, confirming you own every account and asking what happens if you stop. Walk away from guaranteed rankings, unverifiable results and paid links.
On this page
  1. The 10 questions
  2. Red flags and green flags
  3. Questions that matter specifically in Nigeria
  4. How to compare two or three proposals
  5. What a good first month looks like
  6. When to do it yourself instead
  7. Before you talk to anyone
  8. How we answer these questions

Hiring an agency to get your business found on Google and AI assistants is a real investment, and the market in Nigeria is crowded. Some agencies are excellent.

Some sell reports full of charts that never turn into a single phone call. And because “AI SEO” is new, it is easy for anyone to add it to their services list.

We are an AI search agency ourselves, so read this with that in mind. But these are the questions we would want any founder to ask us, and the questions we would ask if we were hiring.

A good agency will welcome them. One that dodges them has told you what you need to know.

The 10 questions

Checklist of 10 questions to ask an AI SEO agency in Nigeria before hiring, from results in 90 days to what happens if you stop
Ask all ten before you sign anything.

1. “What will be different for my business in 90 days?”

You want a specific answer tied to your goals: which searches and AI questions you should start appearing for, which pages will exist, what will change on your Google profile and how enquiries should move. “We’ll improve your online presence” isn’t an answer.

2. “Can I see results I can check myself?”

Ask for named clients and the exact searches they now win. Then check: search those terms on Google and Maps, ask ChatGPT the same question, look at the client’s website.

Screenshots are a start, but anything you can verify yourself is worth far more. If every case study is anonymous, ask why.

3. “Which buyer questions and AI prompts will you track?”

AI visibility can’t be measured with rankings alone.

A serious agency will agree a list of the questions your buyers ask, such as “best property lawyer in Lekki” or “is [your company] legit?”, and check them in the main assistants every month, recording whether you are named and which sources are quoted.

4. “How will you measure enquiries, not just rankings?”

Rankings and traffic matter only if they lead to calls, WhatsApp messages, bookings and sales.

Ask how the agency will connect its work to leads: call tracking, form tracking, asking new clients how they found you, or analytics that shows visits from AI assistants.

5. “What exactly will you do each month?”

Get the scope in writing: how many pages written or improved, what work on your Google profile, which listings and links, what reporting. A clear scope protects both sides and makes progress easy to judge.

6. “Who does the work, and who do I speak to?”

Some agencies sell with a senior person and hand the work to someone you never meet, or to freelancers. That isn’t always bad, but you should know.

Ask who writes the content, who handles technical changes and who answers when you have a question.

7. “Do you work with my direct competitors?”

For local and AI search, only a few businesses get named for each question. An agency representing two estate agents in Lekki has a conflict. Ask directly.

8. “How do you build links and mentions, and what won’t you do?”

Good answers mention real directories, industry associations, local media, partners and content worth citing.

Bad answers mention “packages” of hundreds of links, private networks or paid placements.

Those can get your site penalised, and they don’t build the kind of trust AI assistants look for.

9. “Who owns the website, content and accounts?”

Your domain, website, Google Business Profile, Search Console, analytics and content should belong to your business from day one, with the agency given access, not the other way round.

This is one of the most common problems we see when businesses switch agencies.

10. “What happens if we stop working together?”

Ask about notice periods and handover, and whether anything stops working when you leave. Some arrangements include websites or tools that disappear when the contract ends. Know before you start.

Red flags and green flags

Comparison of red flags (guaranteed rankings, unverifiable results, paid links, jargon reports, agency-owned accounts) and green flags when choosing an AI SEO agency
What to walk away from, and what to look for.
  • Guaranteed first place. Nobody controls Google’s or ChatGPT’s results. Promises like “number one in 7 days, guaranteed” for competitive terms are a warning sign.
  • Results you can’t check. Anonymous clients, cropped screenshots and no names.
  • Shortcuts. Bought reviews, keyword-stuffed business names, fake addresses and paid link packages can get your profile suspended or your site penalised.
  • Reports without enquiries. Pages of charts with no mention of calls, messages or clients.
  • Locked-in accounts. The agency owns your profile or domain.

Questions that matter specifically in Nigeria

  • Do they understand how your buyers search? Lagos and Abuja buyers search by area, often with WhatsApp as the next step. Diaspora buyers search from abroad and check carefully. An agency should talk about this without being prompted.
  • Do they know the local sources AI quotes? Nigerian directories, property portals, business publications and associations matter for local answers. Ask which ones they would target for you.
  • Do they cover Bing? ChatGPT and Copilot lean on Bing, which many Nigerian sites have never set up. Read why Bing matters for ChatGPT and Copilot.
  • Can they help with the step after the search? Fast replies on WhatsApp and follow-up often decide whether visibility turns into clients. See our guide to WhatsApp lead automation.

How to compare two or three proposals

Once you have proposals in hand, they can be hard to compare. One promises “30 keywords”, another “full AI optimisation”, a third “monthly content”. Put them side by side against the same five questions:

  1. What outcome is each one aiming for? Calls, enquiries, bookings or sales, stated for your business, beats rankings alone.
  2. What will actually be produced? Pages, profile work, listings, links, reports. Count the deliverables, not the adjectives.
  3. How will progress be shown? Monthly reports you can understand, with enquiries and AI mentions, not just traffic.
  4. What is the first month’s plan? A proposal with a clear first month usually means the agency has done this before.
  5. What are the terms? Minimum period, notice, ownership and handover.

The cheapest proposal is rarely the best value if it delivers nothing you can measure, and the most expensive isn’t automatically better. Choose the one whose plan you understand and whose results you were able to check.

What a good first month looks like

Whoever you hire, the first month should leave you with something concrete, not just “onboarding”. A reasonable first month includes:

  • A baseline: where you appear today on Google, Maps and the main AI assistants for an agreed list of buyer questions, with screenshots.
  • An audit with priorities: what is holding you back, in plain language, in order of impact.
  • Quick fixes done: Google profile corrections, Bing set-up, indexing issues and obvious page fixes.
  • A plan for the next two months: which pages, which listings and links, which questions you are aiming to win.
  • Tracking agreed: how enquiries will be counted from now on.

If a month passes and you can’t say what changed, ask why.

When to do it yourself instead

Not every business needs an agency.

If you have a single location, a small number of services, and someone on your team with a few hours a week, you can do a lot yourself: complete and maintain your Google Business Profile, ask every customer for a review, make your details consistent, set up Bing and write clear pages for your main services. Our AI search checklist for Nigerian founders lists the steps.

An agency earns its fee when the stakes are higher: high-value clients, competitive categories, several locations or markets, buyers abroad, or a team with no time to keep the work going every week.

The test is simple. Will the extra clients the agency brings in be worth more than the cost, within a timeframe you can live with?

Before you talk to anyone

You will get more out of every agency conversation if you know three things:

  1. The two or three services you most want more clients for.
  2. The areas or countries those clients are in.
  3. Where you appear today: search your main service and area on Google and Maps, and ask ChatGPT who the best providers are. Screenshot the results.

If you are still getting to grips with the terms, start with GEO vs SEO: what changes when buyers ask AI, and our guide on what to expect in your first 90 days.

How we answer these questions

We publish our client results with names, so you can check them: Kings Geo-Consult ranks first on Google for “best land surveyor in Ikeja”, Gallant Naija Laundry reached first for “premium laundry service Ikeja” on day six, and Google’s AI Overview names Ire-Ayo Crown Foods first for snack manufacturers in Ibadan.

See them on our client results page, read how we work, or book a free strategy call and ask us all ten questions.

Common questions

Is an AI SEO agency different from a normal SEO agency?

The best agencies do both.

An AI SEO agency should cover classic SEO and also the work that gets you named in ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Google's AI Overviews: consistency across the web, Bing indexing, mentions on trusted sites and prompt tracking. Ask how they handle each.

Should I hire a Nigerian agency or an international one?

For Nigerian buyers, local knowledge matters: how people search by area, which directories and publications AI assistants quote here, and how buyers in Lagos or Abuja decide.

If you also sell abroad, check the agency has worked with clients targeting those markets.

How quickly should I expect results?

Fixes to your Google profile and website can show within weeks for specific local searches. Competitive categories take months. Be wary of anyone promising first place in days for a competitive term.

How do I check an agency's results?

Ask for named clients, then search the terms they claim yourself, in Google and in ChatGPT. Look at the client's site and Google profile. Ask if you can speak to one of them.

Written by IYD Editorial

Visibility & Conversion Strategist

Book a free strategy call